Why Does HandBrake Save DVD to M4V not MP4 Video File?

John Salley

Dec 20, 2016 08:15 am / Posted by John Salley to BD/DVD Backup, Reviews

How to open M4V file with general video players through new Mac OS Sierra? Why does HandBrake save DVD to M4V not MP4 file? Certainly, discussion about Handbrake rip DVD issues never stops. At some point Handbrake DVD decoder users found there were constant DVD video playback issues as Handbrake rips new DVD movies to M4V format, not MP4. While you are complaining about Handbrake cannot read DVD, some people are beefing about the MP4/M4V option in Handbrake like the cases below.

” I’m using the latest version of Handbrake on the Mac. When I rip a DVD, handbrake shows that it will rip to the mp4 format. However, when the rip is complete, the file format is m4v. How can I make sure that the file is ripped to the mp4 format not M4V using Handbrake?”

People want to rip DVD to MP4 but Handbrake usually saves DVD as M4V not MP4. If you invovle in the same trouble as the above question, You may need to know the typical problem is that QuickTime as well as some other consoles like Android reports an error when playing the encoded file. And the best best solution to cope with this HandBrake DVD Ripping Error. Learn below guide how to slove HandBrake saving DVD as M4V issue with the best Mac HandBrake Alternative.


Reasons Why Handbrake Saves DVD as M4V Not MP4

Like the cases above, Handbrake (Since version 0.9.5) saves DVD and video as M4V rather than familiar MP4. Why? Generally, Handbrake stores audio in the AAC format, which possibly passes through AC3 audio from a DVD in an MP4 file. For MP4 files, Handbrake will automatically use the M4V extension if your output contains AC3 audio, SRT subtitles or chapter markers. The reason for this is that QuickTime or any QT based apps will refuse to play a MP4 file with these features enabled, unless the extension is .m4v.

Despite Handbrake mentions that there are no differences between MP4 and M4V and there is an option in HandBrakes preferences to select the extension, it’s recommended not to change M4V to MP4 in Handbrake if containing AC3 audio as it therefore won’t be played on QuickTime.

How to Open and Play HandBrake M4V File?

Apple TV needs the .m4v file extension to know how to deal with the AC3 in the mp4 container. Chapters and AC3 audio can only be seen by QuickTime if you change the file extension from .mp4 to .m4v. QuickTime or any QT-based app cannot play a MP4 file with these features enabled, unless it has the extension “.m4v”. So you should not change to MP4 the extension of a file if it is as M4V containing a3c audio. That’s why the Apple TV preset changes it in the destination field. >> How to Free Rip DVD to Apple TV?

The simplest way to open and play M4V file is to change the file extension back and forth between M4V and MP4. That is, HandBrake M4V to MP4, or HandBrake MP4 to M4V.

To the file extension from M4V to MP4 is the simplest but not an omnipotent way to play HandBrakde M4V file. In order to solve HandBrake Saving DVD as M4V issue flawlessly, the following solutions highly recommended.

Learn>> HandBrake Supported Input/Output/Subtitle Formats

1. Play M4V files by Apple QuickTime Player, Windows Media Player Classic, VLC media player, MPlayer, RealPlayer and all-in-one video/audio player DAPlayer;

2. Convert M4V to MP4, AVI, WMV, MOV, FLV, etc using Top DVD converter;

3. As open source software to rip DVD, Handbrake is pretty outstanding. But it’s not that easy to use especially for beginners with an oversimplified interface, poor presets and limited output formats. So it is highly suggested taking a Handbrake alternative to rip DVD with ease.

Find the best HandBrake alternative (such as Pavtube BDMagic for Mac/Pavtube BDMagic) to rip DVD to H.264 MP4, AVI, MPEG, MKV, FLV, WMV, H.265/HEVC MP4, etc directly. They can also convert DVD for movie playback on all iPhone, iPad, iTouch, iTunes, Air Playit and any other popular Android and Windows devices. They also support ripping DVD to ISO, MPEG2, MP3, JPEG, or converting DVD ISO to AVI, MP4, and so on. In addition, This Top Handbrake Alternative fully supports Disney and Sony protected DVDs, and can select the correct main movie title by default during ripping. Learn >> Capture a video from DVD.

Ready to Free Trail and Buy This Top Handbrake Alternative for Mac?

mac download
mac buy
 Handbrake Error Solutions:

Compare Handbrake And Handbrake Alternative

Pavtube BDMagic Handbrake
Conversion Object
Common DVD file /source
Common Blu-ray file/source
Copy protection DVD source
Copy protection Blu-ray source
Main Features
Full disk copy/ directly (main movie)copy
NVIDIA CUDA/AMD APP acceleration
Forced subtitles
Video preview
Batch conversion
Video editing
Output Video Formats
Other various sd/hd video formats
Output Audio Formats
Common audio formats


HandBrake Alternative features better stability and compatibility than Handbrake itself. Has been tested time after time by our team, Pavtube BDMagic is proved as 100% safe upon Windows. As for unexpected issues, their prompt technique support will offer you timely assistance (response within 24 hours; for HandBrake however, you need to wait months until they publish next version).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *